You are right from your side, I am right from mine.
–Bob Dylan “One Too Many Mornings”
I don’t find very many quotes from Dylan that aren’t spot on. 99.999% of his poetry is impossibly true and astoundingly real. They don’t give the Nobel Prize in Literature to just any drifter from Minnesota. But, the above line is where Bob and I part ways.
Maybe I was in the Debate Club in high school, but I can’t remember if I was. But, in some class, at some point a teacher told the class that a successful debater should be able to argue both sides to a question. In theory, that sounds interesting. But it also sounds a bit strange. If you look at it from a salesperson’s point of view then one should be able to sell a refrigerator to an Inuit. Nice, but what’s the point?
Slight shift here, stay with me.
I have been interested in Sociology, Anthropology, Religion and History for much of my adult life. I read many books on rituals, customs, ideologies and beliefs. I tried to keep an open mind to all sides of all issues. But in the last several decades, I have come to a truth. And that truth is that every custom or ritual is not, by definition, true or wise or even just.
There are not two sides to every story.
When I look at the world now, I see it in a new fresher light. Many things that cultures do are proper…and many are not.
It’s so easy for people to stand back and say: “Oh, it’s their custom. We must respect that.” That is a very dangerous worldview.
Using this logic (does that even exist anymore?), a German citizen in 1939 could justify any comment about what the real problem in society is…and propose a solution. I’m tired of trying to see things from another POV when that view is simply wrong.
-Preventing the women in many religions to be fully free and equal to men is wrong.
-Customs that go back a millennia, i.e., the genital mutilation of young girls is not justifiable in any way. What God would want such a thing? The answer is no loving God would. It’s simply control over females, by men who use Holy Texts as an excuse.
-Cult leaders who stand at their pulpits and say: “God has told me that I can have as many wives as I would like…and they be thirteen-years-old.” Do I need to even say anything about the idiocy of this practice.
I could go on, but that would darken my spirits even more than they already are. Lies and hypocrisy have cast a dark and evil blanket over the world. The USA’s government has to share the blame.
Dylan’s quote is true on one level at least. In personal relationships, each person brings their own baggage into the room. That burden (baggage) can be the result of a lifetime of experiences. As long as that isn’t used to justify violence, it’s okay.
As long as religion and God aren’t there to support someone’s hatred or prejudice, then I have no problem.
Some things are true and good, and some things are false and evil.
There’s no debate.